|
The Market Value of Liabilities Issue
|
| |
|
| |
A movement is afoot that would require public
pension plans to calculate and publish their market value of
liabilities, also known as the plan's termination
liability. A termination liability requires using a
risk-free rate of investment return--generally
around four to five percent--to discount
liabilities, rather than a return based on a
diversified portfolio, which is generally seven to
eight percent. Corporate
pension plans are required to calculate a MVL,
chiefly so that in the case of bankruptcy or sale
of the firm, the plan's liabilities are known.
Primary arguments against requiring public
pension plans to calculate and publish a MVL are
1) public entities, such as states and cities, are
essentially perpetual and will not go out of
business or be acquired; and 2) participants in
public pension plans generally are entitled to
continue accruing benefits once those benefits
have been established. MVL opponents believe
that these factors render a MVL figure irrelevant.
MVL opponents further believe that one consequence
of a MVL would be to significantly--and
needlessly--inflate the
plan's current and projected required costs.
The MVL issue has been referred to as Financial Economics.
However, FE is a broader discipline that encompasses more than just the MVL issue. The resources below
are intended to inform the MVL discussion.
|
| |
NASRA Resolution on Public Employee Retirement System Accounting Standards and Actuarial
Methodologies |
| |
Why Public Sector Accounting and Financial Reporting Is--And Should Be--Different, Governmental Accounting Standards Board |
| |
The Case for Stocks in Pension Funds, David T. Kausch, FSA, Gabriel, Roeder, Smith & Co. |
| |
The Case Against Stock in Public Pension Funds, Lawrence N. Bader and Jeremy Gold |
| |
Financial Economics and Public Retirement Systems, Presentation by Paul Angelo of The Segal Company |
| |
What Ails Public Pensions? And What Can Be Done to Strengthen Them?, Richard Ennis, CFA,
Ennis Knupp & Associates, Inc. |
| |
The
Pension Actuary's Guide to Financial Economics, Joint AAA/SOA Task Force on Financial Economics and the Actuarial Model |
| |
Liability Aware Investing for Defined Benefit Pension Funds, Armand Yamboa, FSA, Ennis Knupp
& Associates, Inc. |
| |
In Support of the Weatherman, Dimitry Mindlin, CDI Advisors |
| |
Windmill Fighters in Potemkin Villages, Dimitry Mindlin, ASA, MAAA, Wilshire Consulting |
| |
Press Release: PBGC Announces New Investment Policy |
|
|
|
|
|